About and methodology

Genups is an independent resource on software quality: testing, accessibility, security, performance and AI readiness.

Genups is published by RedevIO Ltd, a small Scottish software company with more than twenty years of hands-on software testing behind it. We write for testers, developers and the small teams who ship software without a dedicated QA department.

What we publish

  • Guides and checklists that start with a short answer and end with their sources.
  • Tool profiles, built from vendor documentation and our own use. A profile has no score.
  • Reviews, only after we have used a tool on a real project. A review has a score.
  • Comparisons of two tools, side by side.
  • Statistics, every figure linked to its original source and year.
  • Research reports from our own data, with the method set out in full.

How we profile and review tools

A profile records what a tool does, what it costs, who it suits and its known limits, from the vendor's own documentation and our use of it. We date every profile and update it when the tool changes.

A review goes further. We use the tool on a real project for at least a week, say how long and what for, and score it. We pay for our own subscriptions where we can, and say so when a vendor gives us access.

How we score

Each reviewed tool is scored from 0 to 10 on the criteria that matter in its category, for example ease of use, quality of evidence, integrations and value for money. The overall score is the plain average, and every line is shown on the review.

  • 8 and up: keep it.
  • 6 to 8: good, with caveats you should read.
  • Under 6: look elsewhere.

Vendors never see a review before it is published and cannot pay to change a score.

Disclosure policy

Our own products. RedevIO Ltd makes Holstr, a test recording tool. Holstr has a profile in the directory, clearly marked as ours, with a grey "not scored" tag. We never review or score it, never rank it, and comparisons that include it set out the facts without a verdict. Our build process enforces these rules: a page that breaks them cannot be published.

Balance. Most of what we publish is educational and does not mention Holstr at all. It appears only where it is genuinely relevant, alongside other tools.

Affiliate links. Some links may earn us a commission. Any page that has them says so at the top, and commissions never change a score.

Corrections

Tools and standards change quickly. If something here is wrong or out of date, tell us and we will fix it and show the date of the update.